Derek Morgan
Derek Morgan
review offer, man working on laptop
Derek Morgan
Derek Morgan

    How to Review an Offer When Selling Your Property

    Receiving offers on your property can be both exhilarating and nerve-wracking, like discovering a treasure chest buried in your backyard. As a seller, you may find yourself wondering if the offer you've received is a golden opportunity or a fool's gold trap. Evaluating offers is a critical step in the property-selling process. It's not just about the highest number on the table; it's about understanding the nuances and implications of each offer and choosing the one that aligns best with your goals and priorities. Think of it as a game of poker - to win, you must assess the hand you've been dealt, weigh your options, and play your cards right. Fear not! We’re here to help you decipher the hidden messages in the offers you receive and empower you to make informed decisions that benefit you.

    Understanding the Components of an Offer

    Purchase Price

    The purchase price is the heart of any property offered. It's the amount the buyer is willing to pay for your property. When reviewing offers, ask yourself if the offered price aligns with your expectations, local market conditions, and recent sales of comparable properties. Don't get lost in emotions or wishful thinking. Stick to the facts and data to evaluate the offer's strength. Additionally, consider the buyer's pre-approval letter and qualifications – a solid financial foundation can support a higher purchase price.

    Earnest Money Deposit

    An earnest money deposit (EMD) serves as a show of good faith from the buyer, indicating their commitment to the purchase. Typically, the EMD ranges from 1% to 3% of the purchase price. A larger deposit signals a more serious buyer; however, weighing it against other factors in the offer is essential. Ensure that the agreed-upon amount is held in escrow and includes a clause for its return if the transaction falls through due to contingencies.

    For more information, check out Understanding Earnest Money Deposits.


    Contingencies provide an escape route for buyers if specific conditions aren't met during the transaction. Common contingencies include financing, appraisal, and inspections. Understand how each contingency can affect your property sale. For example, a low appraisal may require renegotiation of the purchase price, while a problematic inspection report might lead to costly repairs or additional negotiations. Evaluate how flexible and cooperative the buyer appears to be when it comes to contingencies, as their attitude can significantly impact the transaction's smoothness.

    To learn more, read Evaluating Contingencies in Real Estate Contracts: Protecting Interests and Closing Deals.

    Closing Date

    The closing date is the day when the property's ownership transfers. Ideally, this should be a mutually agreeable date. As a seller, consider how the proposed closing date aligns with your plans, such as moving arrangements or other time-sensitive matters. Make sure the date is realistic for meeting all requirements, such as financing and contingencies. Keep in mind that a fast closing may be attractive, but it may not be feasible for all parties involved. Always evaluate the closing date with a balance between desire and reality.

    Evaluating the Offer's Financial Aspects

    Comparing the Offer Price to Your Asking Price

    One of the first things to consider when reviewing an offer is how closely the offer price aligns with your asking price. A higher offer price could mean smooth sailing to close, while a lower one might signal the start of tough negotiations. Keep in mind that your property's market value, as well as the current state of the real estate market, should play a significant role in guiding your decision. An offer that matches or surpasses your asking price is like a cherry on top of your cake, but don't be too quick to brush off lower offers—they might have other perks that make them worth considering, such as waived contingencies or all-cash offers.

    Buyer's Financing Method

    The next aspect to analyze is the buyer's financing method—how they plan to pay for their new home. While an all-cash offer has an irresistible allure for its simplicity and speediness, most buyers will opt for a mortgage. In this case, you should review the buyer's pre-approval letter which ensures they have the necessary financial backing. Delve into the details, such as the bank's terms and conditions, and verify the pre-approval letter's authenticity. Remember that a well-financed buyer can imply a smoother closing process and a reduced likelihood of any last-minute financial hiccups.

    Weighing the Earnest Money Deposit

    An earnest money deposit (EMD) is the buyer's way of saying, "I'm serious about buying this property." In essence, it's a percentage of the offer price the buyer places in an escrow account as a good-faith gesture. When reviewing an offer, take note of the EMD amount. A higher deposit reflects a committed buyer who's more likely to follow through with the purchase. But tread carefully—while the EMD is refundable in specific circumstances (e.g. if contingencies aren't met), things could get messy if the deal falls apart. And don't forget, you'll need to return the EMD if the sale doesn't go through.

    Factoring in Concessions and Requested Repairs

    Lastly, when evaluating an offer's financial aspects, consider any concessions and requested repairs. Concessions are instances where the seller agrees to cover costs that the buyer would typically handle, like closing fees or the home warranty. Requested repairs, on the other hand, are improvements the buyer asks the seller to complete before moving in. Weigh these factors against the other financial aspects of the offer—sometimes, a lower asking price coupled with minimal concessions and repair requests can be more favorable than a higher price with a laundry list of demands. Focus on the offer's net effect on your pocketbook, and let that guide your decision.

    Assessing the Offer's Terms and Conditions

    Contingencies and their Impact

    Contingencies are clauses in a real estate contract that allow the buyer or seller to back out without penalty under certain circumstances. When reviewing an offer on your property, pay close attention to these contingencies, as they can significantly impact the success of the transaction. For instance, a home inspection contingency allows the buyer to walk away if the home inspection reveals significant issues. Meanwhile, a financing contingency permits the buyer to back out if they can't secure a mortgage. Understand each contingency and consider the potential risks to your sale. Be cautious of offers riddled with contingencies, as they may lower the likelihood of a successful closing.

    Closing Date and Flexibility

    The closing date is the day when the property officially changes hands. Typically, this date is 30-45 days after the contract is signed. Review your offer's proposed closing date and consider whether it aligns with your plans. Some buyers may request a specific closing date to accommodate their schedule, while others might be more flexible. Flexibility is key when selling your property. If the proposed closing date doesn't work for you, consider negotiating with the buyer to find a mutually agreeable timeframe. Remember that delays in closing can impact your moving plans and carrying costs, so weigh the benefits of flexibility against the potential consequences.

    Post-Closing Possession Agreements

    A post-closing possession agreement allows the seller to remain in the property for a specified period after closing. This can be beneficial when coordinating your move to a new home or if you need extra time to relocate. When reviewing your offer, consider if a post-closing possession agreement would be advantageous and if the buyer is amenable to such an arrangement. Keep in mind that post-closing possession agreements can introduce potential complications, such as liability and insurance concerns. As always, consult with your real estate agent or attorney for guidance on crafting a mutually beneficial agreement.

    Special Clauses or Stipulations

    Finally, review any special clauses or stipulations included in the offer. These might encompass unique requests from the buyer, such as leaving specific appliances, making pre-closing repairs, or agreeing to a rent-back arrangement. Carefully consider if the requested terms are reasonable and beneficial to both parties. If necessary, negotiate with the buyer to arrive at a mutually agreeable solution. Always keep your core goals and motivations at the forefront of your decision-making process, ensuring you generate the optimal outcome for your property sale.

    Packing before moving

    Negotiating the Offer

    Deciding on Your Counteroffer Strategy

    The art of negotiating the offer begins with formulating a solid counteroffer strategy. Reflect on your property's worth and the buyer's starting offer, then determine a realistic counteroffer that you are both comfortable with and confident in. Some sellers choose to stick to their asking price or counter just slightly below it to project confidence in the property's value. Conversely, others may provide a more flexible counteroffer to encourage a quicker sale. Keep in mind that each negotiation is unique, and your strategy must adapt accordingly. Consult with your real estate agent for advice on the most effective approach for your situation.

    Read more in How to Submit a Counter-Offer When Selling Your Property: A Step-by-Step Guide.

    Timing and Communication

    Timing and communication play crucial roles in the negotiation process. Respond to the buyer's offer as quickly as possible, but also take the time to review the offer thoroughly and prepare a well-thought-out counteroffer. Be mindful of extending deadlines, as this can dampen the buyer's interest or even lead to the withdrawal of their offer. Maintain clear and open lines of communication with your real estate agent and the buyer's agent to avoid misunderstandings. Transparency is essential in negotiations, so don't be afraid to be candid about your expectations and concerns.

    Working with your Real Estate Agent

    Your real estate agent is a vital ally in the negotiation process. This professional has amassed extensive experience in handling offers, counteroffers, and the intricacies involved in property sales. Ensure that you work closely with them and seek their counsel regularly. They can provide invaluable insight into the current market conditions, the most effective negotiation strategies for your situation, and guidance on whether your counteroffer aligns with the property's value. Keep the lines of communication open and be receptive to their advice, as your goal is the same: closing the sale at the best possible price.

    Preparing for Multiple Offers

    In the event you receive multiple offers on your property, preparation is key. Evaluate each offer based on its financial aspects, terms, and conditions, and prioritize them according to your needs and preferences. Be transparent with all potential buyers about the presence of competing offers and establish a clear timeline for any counteroffers or final offers. Be prepared to handle bidding wars, but also be cautious of the risks involved - as some buyers can back out if they feel overwhelmed by the competition. Consult with your real estate agent for guidance on how to navigate multiple offers.

    Making a Final Decision

    Assessing your Priorities

    To make a sound decision, when reviewing an offer on your property, identify your top priorities. Consider factors such as timing, price, and the overall ease of the sale process. Rank these priorities in order of importance, as this will help you determine which offer aligns best with your goals. Do you need to close on the sale quickly? Is the highest price the most critical factor? Or are you more concerned with working with a buyer who is flexible and easy to work with during the negotiations? Recognizing your priorities will help guide you in making an informed decision.

    Balancing Financial and Non-Financial Factors

    Strike a balance between financial and non-financial factors when reviewing offers. While the highest price might seem enticing, don't overlook other essential aspects of the offer, such as contingencies or the buyer's financing. Weigh the pros and cons of each offer, taking into account your priorities, and choose the one that provides the most favorable balance. Remember that a higher-priced offer with problematic contingencies or shaky financing might not always be the best option. Focus on the factors that matter the most to you and your situation.

    Trusting your Instincts

    Trust your gut when reviewing offers and making a decision. Though it's crucial to consider every aspect of an offer, you should also listen to your instincts. Do you feel comfortable working with the potential buyer? Does the offer feel fair to you? Can you imagine a smooth and successful transaction with the buyer? There might be times when your intuition will disagree with your analytical side. In such cases, remember that it's okay to trust your instincts when deciding which offer is best for you. After all, you're the one who knows your property and its real value better than anyone else.

    Understanding the Consequences of Rejecting an Offer

    Be aware of the consequences of rejecting an offer. While you may feel tempted to hold out for a higher bid or more favorable terms, you should remember the risks involved in turning down offers. There are no guarantees that you will receive another offer, let alone a better one. If you decline a reasonable offer, you could potentially lose out on a sale, spend more time on the market, or be forced to lower your asking price. Before rejecting an offer, carefully evaluate your options and the potential outcomes, ensuring you make the choice that best aligns with your priorities and goals.


    In conclusion, reviewing and evaluating offers when selling your property is a crucial process that demands attention to detail and a thorough understanding of the various components involved. Remember to assess your priorities, strike a balance between financial and non-financial factors, trust your instincts, and understand the consequences of rejecting an offer. Armed with this knowledge and a strong partnership with your real estate agent, you'll be well-equipped to close the sale at the best possible price and achieve a successful property transaction.

    Visit to start scanning your local listings! Start a listing on the MLS for free at

    We'd love to hear your thoughts about this article and our blog. Let us know how we did by completing the Unreal Estate Blog Feedback Survey.

    Unreal Estate stacked logo



    Updated January 2023: By using this website, you agree to our Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.

    ⁠Unreal Estate holds real estate brokerage licenses under the following names in multiple states and locations:
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a, LLP)
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a USRealty Brokerage Solutions, LLP)
    Unreal Estate Brokerage LLC
    Unreal Estate Inc. (f/k/a Abode Technologies, Inc. (dba
    Main Office Location: 1500 Conrad Weiser Parkway, Womelsdorf, PA  19567
    California DRE #01527504
    New York § 442-H Standard Operating Procedures
    TREC: Info About Brokerage ServicesConsumer Protection Notice


    If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Unreal Estate Customer Support for help at 1-866-534-3726 
    Open Monday – Friday 9:00 – 5:00 EST with the exception of holidays.

    *See Terms of Service for details.

    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon

    © 2023 Unreal Estate Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    Unreal Estate certified trust badge
    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon