Derek Morgan
Derek Morgan
What is a Contingency in Real Estate
Derek Morgan
Derek Morgan

    How to Submit a Counter-Offer When Selling Your Property: A Step-by-Step Guide

    counter-offer arises when a seller takes a fearless approach to the negotiation process and, rather than accepting or rejecting an offer outright, presents a modified deal in response. Here, the plot thickens, and sellers entrench themselves in a battle of wits, working to achieve the best possible outcome. Often, counter-offers address critical aspects of the initial offer that fell short of expectations, such as the price, terms, or contingencies involved. The goal for buyers and sellers alike is to strike a balance, satisfying both parties and emerging victoriously.

    What is a Counter-offer?

    Why might you need to submit a counter-offer?

    Submitting a counter-offer may become necessary for several reasons. The most common driver is price: an offer might arrive below the seller's expectations, triggering a fight-back. But the game is more complex than just dollar signs, and further causes include conflicts over contingencies, desired closing dates, or property repairs. By crafting a clever counter-offer, you empower yourself to fight for your goals and challenge conventional limitations in the property selling process.

    The role of counter-offers in the property selling process

    Counter-offers play an instrumental role in the property selling process, often acting as a vital bridge in the negotiation journey. A well-crafted counter-offer can successfully steer the transaction towards a mutually beneficial outcome by fighting gatekeeping with access to more favorable conditions. But beware: this strategic weapon should be wielded carefully and responsibly. Overusing counter-offers can lead to a stalemate or even rattle potential buyers enough to walk away from the deal. Used appropriately, however, they serve as a golden ticket to a better outcome - your secret weapon for fighting complexity with simplicity.

    Deciding When to Counter

    Assessing the Initial Offer

    Let's dive right in: when should you submit a counter-offer when selling your property? The first step starts with carefully assessing the initial offer presented by the potential buyer. You've got to pay close attention to the offer price, requested concessions, and contingencies included in the buyer's proposal. Please, don't get swept up in the emotions of seeing that first offer (we know, it's tempting!). Instead, take a step back, review the fine print, and keep your goals in mind. Your property's market value, recent comparable sales, and current market conditions should all play a key role in your assessment. Remember: fighting misinformation with transparency is our mantra.

    To learn more about pricing your property appropriately and the potential drawbacks of pricing it too low, read Is My Property Priced Too Low?

    Factors to Consider Before Countering

    Now that you've reviewed the initial offer, it's time to move on to the factors to consider before submitting a counter-offer. Weigh the pros and cons of the offer you received against your goals, timeline, and financial constraints. Some questions you should ask yourself:

    • Is the offer price acceptable, or can you fight gatekeeping with access by negotiating a higher sale price?

    • Is the buyer requesting too many concessions that may negatively impact your bottom line?

    • Can you live with the proposed contingencies, or should you push for more favorable terms?

    Once you've got your bearings, weigh the risks of potentially losing the buyer if your counter-offer is more than they're willing to accept. Ultimately, your decision to counter should be a calculated move that aligns with your goals and a realistic assessment of the situation.

    Working with Your Real Estate Agent

    Lucky for you, you don't have to navigate these treacherous waters alone! Collaborate closely with your trusted real estate agent, and leverage their expertise to help you decide whether a counter-offer is the right move. Remember, they're there to fight complexity with simplicity on your behalf. They can provide valuable insights into the buyer's motives, current market conditions, and potential negotiation tactics that may lead to a favorable outcome for you.

    A skilled agent will guide you in drafting a strategic counter-offer and provide feedback on the terms they believe will be most effective in reaching an agreement. Open communication and a strong partnership with your agent are crucial during this phase of the selling process, so don't hesitate to lean on their knowledge and experience. With their assistance, you'll be well equipped to submit a counter-offer that strikes the right balance between achieving your goals and maintaining the buyer's interest.

    Preparation for Submitting a Counter-Offer

    Gathering Important Information

    Before diving into negotiations, it's crucial to arm yourself with accurate and up-to-date information about your property and the local market. Research recent sales of properties similar to yours in the area, consult with your real estate agent, and become familiar with your home's unique selling points. A comprehensive Comparable Market Analysis (CMA) can give you insights into market trends and the fair market value of your property. Familiarize yourself with the buyer's preferences, including their top priorities and the factors that are driving their decision-making process. Remember, knowledge is power – and the more informed you are, the stronger your position will be during negotiations.

    For more information about CMA's, check out Finding your Property Value by Making Adjustments to Values in Comps.

    Calculating Your Counter-Offer Price

    When it comes to calculating your counter-offer price, be strategic and realistic. Start by establishing your bottom line – the lowest price you're willing to accept for your property. Next, consider the initial offer and any concessions the buyer has made, such as a quicker closing date or waived contingencies. Take into account any factors that could strengthen your case, like a competitive real estate market or a shortage of similar properties in the area. Finally, don't be afraid to leave some room for negotiation – just remember that it's a delicate balance between standing your ground and finding common ground with the buyer.

    1. Establish your bottom line

    2. Consider the initial offer

    3. Reflect on market conditions

    4. Leave room for negotiation

    Determining Your Negotiation Strategy

    A well-defined negotiation strategy can be the difference between a successful sale and a frustrating stalemate. Start by identifying your priorities – is it a higher sale price, a shorter closing period, or a specific set of contingencies? Consider your willingness to compromise and your desired outcomes for the negotiation. Work closely with your real estate agent to craft a strategy that's tailored to your unique situation and objectives. Remember, the key to successful negotiations is flexibility and adaptability – be prepared to adjust your approach as new information emerges and the bargaining dynamics shift.

    • Identify your priorities

    • Set your desired outcomes

    • Collaborate with your real estate agent

    • Be flexible and adaptable in your approach

    Creating a Counter-Offer Letter

    Essential components of a counter-offer letter

    A well-crafted counter-offer letter should include a few essential components that present your position convincingly and professionally. First, always include the property address to ensure the buyer knows which property the letter refers to. Next, clearly state your proposed selling price and any other terms you'd like to negotiate, such as contingencies or closing date changes. Include reasons for your counter-offer, backed up by market data or specific aspects of the property that justify the changes in price or terms. Demonstrate flexibility where possible to convey your willingness to reach a mutually satisfying agreement. Finally, set a deadline for the buyer's response to encourage prompt action.

    Tips for clear and persuasive communication

    When crafting your counter-offer letter, it's essential to use clear and persuasive language that effectively communicates your position. Consider the following tips:

    • Keep it concise: Aim to be brief and to-the-point, focusing only on the most critical aspects of the negotiation.

    • Use active voice: Write in active voice for a more direct, powerful, and engaging tone.

    • Be diplomatic and respectful: Acknowledge the buyer's interests and concerns without compromising your own.

    • Provide evidence: Reference market data, property comparisons, or expert opinions to support your stance.

    • Avoid ultimatums: Instead of presenting your counter-offer as your final statement, phrase it as a step towards reaching a mutually beneficial agreement.

    Reviewing counter-offer letter with your agent

    Before sending your counter-offer letter to the buyer or their agent, it's wise to review it with your real estate agent. Your agent's experience and market knowledge can provide valuable insights to fine-tune your proposal or identify potential drawbacks. They may suggest revisions to your price, terms, or language to better align with market expectations and improve the chances of a favorable response.

    Collaborating with your agent is an essential step in the counter-offer process, as they can help ensure your letter is professionally written and effectively represents your interests. They can also guide you in navigating any further negotiations and assist in strategizing for potential responses from the buyer. Don't underestimate the importance of their expert guidance in this critical phase of the property selling journey.

    submitting a counter offer online

    Submitting the Counter-Offer

    Timing and method of delivery

    Timing is crucial when submitting a counter-offer. You want to strike a balance between showing urgency and not appearing too eager, which may signal to the buyer that you're desperate. It's generally advised to respond within 24-48 hours, giving you ample time to consult with your real estate agent and carefully craft your response.

    In the digital age, the most common method of delivery is email. However, it's still advisable to follow up with a phone call to ensure the buyer has received the counter-offer, and to gauge their initial reaction. This can also provide an opportunity to establish rapport with the buyer and open the lines of communication for further negotiations.

    Managing expectations and emotions

    Selling a property can be an emotional rollercoaster, especially when offers don't meet your expectations. It's crucial to approach every negotiation as a business transaction, putting emotions aside and focusing on the numbers and terms. 

    Know your absolute bottom line - the minimum amount you're willing to accept - and be prepared to walk away if necessary. Manage your expectations. Market conditions, property condition, and buyer's finances impact the sale price. Stay level-headed, avoid emotional judgment, and make rational decisions to increase chances of achieving desired outcome.

    Navigating multiple counter-offers

    In the event that you receive multiple offers, the negotiation process can become more complex. The key here is to prioritize the factors most important to you - whether it's price, closing date, or the removal of contingencies. Analyze each offer, and work closely with your real estate agent to determine the best strategy for countering and negotiating with each potential buyer.

    When dealing with multiple counter-offers, transparency is vital. You can openly inform buyers that you're working with multiple offers, which may encourage them to submit their best and final offer in response.

    Should you find yourself in a bidding war, it's essential to maintain your composure and stay firm on the terms that you've set forth. Ultimately, the end goal is to sell your property on your terms, secure the best possible outcome, and fight complexity with simplicity in the process.

    Responding to Buyer's Counter to Your Counter-Offer

    Deciding on Further Negotiations

    When the dance of counter-offering continues, establishing your limits and being aware of your needs is crucial. Communication plays a vital role here. Work closely with your real estate agent and have a clear understanding of the buyer's situation. Assess their motivations and financial capabilities, as they could impact negotiations. Be proactive and anticipate potential roadblocks like contingencies, financing, or appraisal issues. By identifying your acceptable price range and deal breakers, you can make well-informed decisions on whether to proceed or hold your ground.

    When to Accept or Walk Away

    Knowing when to accept an offer or walk away from negotiations can be tough. Consider factors such as the state of the local market, the length of time your property has been on the market, and your urgency to sell. If the buyer presents a counter that aligns with your needs and is fair, by all means, accept it. However, if they're unreasonably low or inflexible, it might be better to let it go and focus on other potential buyers. Remember, fighting complexity with simplicity, and picking your battles could prove more beneficial than exhausting yourself in endless negotiations.

    Handling Various Scenarios

    Navigating through various scenarios requires real estate expertise and a keen sense of judgment. For instance, multiple counter-offers can be tricky, but they also open up opportunities to negotiate the best possible price and terms. Carefully analyze and rank the offers based on your priorities. In case of a low-ball offer, respond professionally and courteously, keeping emotions at bay. Sometimes, you may encounter buyers who insist on unusual or unreasonable requests. When faced with these situations, a cool-headed approach and open communication with your agent can help you find creative solutions or decide that it's time to part ways and seek better opportunities elsewhere.

    Finalizing the Deal

    Signing the revised offer

    Congratulations, you've fought complexity with simplicity and reached an agreement with the buyer! It's time to fearlessly put pen to paper and sign the revised offer. Ensure that both parties, along with their respective agents, carefully review the final terms and conditions of the contract. After all, it takes candidness and wit to navigate the world of real estate successfully. Don't let emotions cloud your judgment here – double-check every detail before signing on the dotted line. Once the document is signed by both the buyer and the seller, it becomes legally binding.

    Preparing for the next steps in the property selling process

    Now that you've signed the revised offer, it's time to fight gatekeeping with access and prepare for the next steps in the property selling process. Communicate with your real estate agent to ensure that all contingencies, inspections, and other requirements are met promptly. It's essential to keep a clear line of communication with the buyer and their agent throughout this phase, as transparency is crucial to fostering trust and goodwill. Remember to stay organized and up-to-date with deadlines, scheduling inspections, and any necessary repairs. By being proactive and prepared, you'll be in the best position to tackle any challenges that may arise, empowering you to move forward with ease.

    Learning from your counter-offer experience

    Once the deal is finalized and the property is sold, take the time to reflect on your counter-offer experience. Rebelliously ask yourself what you've learned and how you've grown as a seller. Were there any hiccups or challenges? How can you improve for future transactions? By fearlessly examining your counter-offer journey, you'll gain valuable insights and enhance your negotiation skills. After all, every experience is an opportunity to grow, learn, and challenge conventional thinking. Keep these lessons in mind as you embark on your next real estate adventure, always remembering to fight misinformation with transparency and blaze your own trail in the property market.


    In conclusion, the counter-offer process is an essential tool in the real estate world, acting as a means to negotiate the best possible outcome for both buyers and sellers. Armed with the knowledge provided in this blog post, and paired with the guidance of an experienced real estate agent, you can confidently navigate the counter-offer process and achieve your desired results. Just remember to always keep your goals in mind, maintain open communication with all parties involved, and be prepared to adapt your strategy as needed. Stay fearless and strategic in your negotiations, and you'll be well on your way to successfully fighting complexity with simplicity in the property market.

    Visit to start scanning your local listings!

    We'd love to hear your thoughts about this article and our blog. Let us know how we did by completing the Unreal Estate Blog Feedback Survey.

    Unreal Estate stacked logo



    Updated January 2023: By using this website, you agree to our Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.

    ⁠Unreal Estate holds real estate brokerage licenses under the following names in multiple states and locations:
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a, LLP)
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a USRealty Brokerage Solutions, LLP)
    Unreal Estate Brokerage LLC
    Unreal Estate Inc. (f/k/a Abode Technologies, Inc. (dba
    Main Office Location: 1500 Conrad Weiser Parkway, Womelsdorf, PA  19567
    California DRE #01527504
    New York § 442-H Standard Operating Procedures
    TREC: Info About Brokerage ServicesConsumer Protection Notice


    If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Unreal Estate Customer Support for help at 1-866-534-3726 
    Open Monday – Friday 9:00 – 5:00 EST with the exception of holidays.

    *See Terms of Service for details.

    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon

    © 2023 Unreal Estate Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    Unreal Estate certified trust badge
    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon