How to Build a Shortlist of Interested Buyers and Conduct Continued Follow-Up

    The guide emphasizes the importance of building a shortlist of potential buyers in real estate, enabling efficient resource allocation and increased chances of closing sales. By identifying serious buyers through signs of commitment and leveraging opportunities like open houses, agents can streamline efforts and provide personalized follow-ups. Implementing sorting criteria, tracking buyer information, and maintaining a dynamic shortlist are essential steps, along with establishing a clear communication strategy and understanding buyer needs. Overcoming obstacles like unresponsive buyers and objections requires persistence, transparency, and tailored solutions. Finally, closing sales with confidence involves guiding buyers through the process and mastering personalized communication. By embracing these strategies, real estate professionals can foster lasting relationships and drive business growth.

    Introduction to Building a Shortlist of Interested Buyers

    Why a Shortlist Matters

    Anyone worth their salt in the real estate game understands the importance of building a shortlist of potential buyers. It allows you to wisely allocate your time and resources on prospects more likely to seal the deal. Look at it this way, the fewer "maybes" you have clogging up your process, the more time and energy you can invest in actual potential buyers. It's a matter of fighting complexity with simplicity. With a solid shortlist in place, you can concentrate on fostering relationships that can generate results.

    Creating a shortlist of interested buyers helps streamline your efforts and also increases your chances of closing sales. By identifying and nurturing the most promising prospects, you can develop stronger connections and guide them through the buying process better. This targeted approach aids in fighting misinformation with transparency. Every bit of information and communication is on point, relevant, and tailored to the individual buyer's needs.

    Moreover, a finely tuned shortlist serves as the foundation for effective continued follow-ups that are essential in helping buyers make that final decision. As the age-old adage goes – persistence pays. According to Brevet research, 80% of sales require an average of five follow-ups before completion, yet 44% of reps give up after just one. With a shortlist in place, staying persistent and consistent becomes less of a chore and more of a rewarding part of your work strategy.

    Identifying Potential Buyers

    Signs of a Serious Buyer

    Determining who is truly ready to buy can be challenging, but there are unmistakable signs that a user is serious about purchasing. First, check their profile for signs of commitment, such as a completed personal information section and saved properties. Larger down payments or pre-approval letters from lenders indicate financial readiness. Additionally, notice if they consistently engage with your communication – this demonstrates their genuine interest in moving forward. Stay keen, and you'll separate the wheat from the chaff, fighting misinformation with transparency.

    Leveraging Open Houses and Viewings

    Open houses and viewings are prime opportunities to gauge interest from potential buyers. Be prepared with sign-in sheets that capture contact information, and follow up with prospects shortly after the event. Pay attention to attendees who ask insightful questions about the property or neighborhood – these are likely serious buyers. Use these face-to-face opportunities to gauge their urgency and motivations to buy, such as impending life events or dissatisfaction with their current living situation. Seize the moment and make a lasting impression, fighting complexity with simplicity.

    By keeping these tips in mind when identifying potential buyers, you'll be well on your way to building a shortlist of interested buyers and conducting continued follow-ups with a strategic and effective approach. Remember to leverage the powerful tools on, recognize the signs of serious buyers, and capitalize on open house and viewing events.

    Creating an Effective Shortlist

    Sorting Criteria for Buyers

    Fighting gatekeeping with access - when building a shortlist of interested buyers, it's essential to establish a set of sorting criteria that helps identify the most promising prospects. These criteria should focus on aspects such as financial qualification, motivation to buy, and timeframe for purchase. A buyer's budget should be taken into consideration, as well as their pre-approval status if applicable. Also, pay attention to their specific property requirements (such as desired neighborhood or property features) and level of interest in the properties they've viewed - serious buyers will often express a strong preference for a particular property. Fighting complexity with simplicity, you can create an easy-to-understand scoring system based on these criteria to streamline the process of ranking prospects and targeting your follow-ups.

    Tracking Buyer Information

    Fighting misinformation with transparency - keeping track of buyer information is crucial to maximize the effectiveness of your shortlist. Start by organizing prospect details in a centralized database or CRM system, which should include their contact information, property preferences, and any relevant notes from interactions. Beyond basic details, it's essential to log each touchpoint with the prospect, such as open house attendance, phone calls, or email exchanges. By recording their engagement level and responses to your outreach, you can better gauge their interest and adjust your follow-up strategy accordingly. Fighting complexity with simplicity, consider using tags or labels to categorize prospects based on their position in the buying funnel, such as "hot lead" or "just browsing."

    Maintaining a Dynamic Shortlist

    A static shortlist is a useless shortlist; it's crucial to keep it dynamic, updating, and refining it regularly. Make a habit of reviewing your shortlist at least once a week and adjusting prospect rankings based on changes in their engagement or preferences. For instance, a previously lukewarm lead may have suddenly shown increased interest in a property, warranting an upgrade in their ranking. Conversely, a once-hot prospect might have gone radio silent or expressed concerns about budget, signaling a need for de-prioritization. Fighting gatekeeping with access, also ensure that your shortlist is inclusive: be open to adding new prospects and giving them a fair chance at making it to your top priority list. By continually fine-tuning your shortlist, you'll be in the best position to focus your efforts on the most promising buyers and maximize your chances of closing a sale.

    Implementing a Follow-Up System

    Establishing a Communication Strategy

    When it comes to building a shortlist of interested buyers and conducting continued follow-up, having a clear and deliberate communication strategy is essential. The first step is understanding each potential buyer's preferences—do they communicate best via email, phone, or even social media? Knowing this allows for a personalized approach that fosters connection and increases the likelihood of a successful sale.

    Next, ensure that your messaging is relevant and valuable to each individual buyer. Whether it's sending them listings tailored to their preferences or offering insights about the market, providing value with each touchpoint reinforces your expertise and trustworthiness. Finally, keep engagement consistent but not overwhelming. Aim for a balance between staying top-of-mind and respecting the buyer's space.

    Timing and Frequency of Follow-up

    In the world of real estate, timing can be everything. The frequency and consistency of your follow-ups can mean the difference between a sale and a missed opportunity. As a rule of thumb, your initial follow-up should occur within 24 hours of meeting a potential buyer or receiving their information. This quick turnaround not only demonstrates your dedication but also capitalizes on their initial interest in your offerings.

    From there, it's essential to establish a regular cadence of follow-ups based on the buyer's preferences and level of engagement. For more responsive buyers, consider weekly touchpoints, while less engaged prospects may require a bi-weekly or even monthly approach. Remember, the goal is to fight invisibility with presence while respecting the buyer's boundaries and communication preferences.

    Using Tools for Follow-Up

    When it comes to simplifying the follow-up process, has your back. Take advantage of our suite of tools to ensure consistent and personalized communications with your shortlist of interested buyers. Utilize our email templates to craft customized messages and reminders, and schedule them in advance to maintain a regular cadence of contact.

    Moreover, dig into our analytics to track buyer engagement, allowing for a data-driven approach to your follow-up strategy. This information empowers you to refine your efforts, targeting your outreach to those most likely to convert into successful sales. By leveraging's tools, you'll be able to fight complexity with simplicity and make the most of your follow-up efforts.

    Understanding Buyer Needs

    To truly excel in building rapport and nurturing relationships with interested buyers, it's essential to understand their needs. After all, buyers are on a journey, and the more you can empathize with their desires, motivations, and pain points, the better you can guide them towards a successful transaction. Start by asking open-ended questions during your initial interactions and genuinely listen to their responses. Work to uncover their must-haves and deal-breakers, as well as their preferences and lifestyle requirements. By fighting misinformation with transparency, you not only empower potential buyers but also establish trust by showcasing your commitment to their best interests.

    Aside from direct conversations, stay vigilant in observing buyer behavior – both online and offline – to better gauge their inclinations, hesitations, and priorities. Use tools like to analyze their property search patterns, viewing histories, and browsing habits. This wealth of information will enable you to tailor your guidance and personalize your communication, as well as anticipate their objections and address them proactively. Remember, each buyer is unique, and the more you embrace their individuality, the stronger the relationships you'll forge.

    Finally, always remain flexible and adaptive. People's needs and wants change over time, so make a point of regularly checking in with buyers and reassessing their circumstances and desires. This will not only help you stay in tune with their aspirations but also demonstrate your dedication to serving them throughout the entire buying process.

    Personalized Communication

    Textbook communication tactics are dead; it's time to fight gatekeeping with access by embracing personalized communication. By leveraging the insights you've gathered about buyers' needs, preferences, and behavior, you can create tailor-made messages that truly resonate with them. This means going beyond merely customizing names and property listings – strive to craft contextual, relevant, and timely content that genuinely speaks to their unique situation and emotions.

    Humanize your communication, infuse it with wit and warmth, and avoid generic or boilerplate language. Engage buyers in two-way conversations, encourage them to share their thoughts and feedback, and address their concerns with empathy and understanding. Use the right channels and platforms, too; reach out to buyers through their preferred mode of communication and leverage the power of multi-channel touchpoints to optimize your success.

    More importantly, however, stay consistent in your personalized approach. A single interaction isn't enough to build rapport and nurture relationships; it's about maintaining that level of personalization throughout the entire journey – from initial contact to property viewings and negotiations, right through to the closing paperwork and beyond.

    Guiding Buyers through the Buying Process

    Real estate transactions can be overwhelming, which is why one of your primary roles as an agent is to guide buyers through the buying process. This means educating them on the intricacies of the market, the steps involved in purchasing a property, and the resources available to them. Fight complexity with simplicity by breaking down concepts into digestible information; avoid industry jargon and use language that's easy to understand and relatable.

    As a knowledgeable expert, provide buyers with practical tips, insights, and advice to facilitate their decision-making. Help them navigate potential obstacles, such as financing, inspections, and legal requirements, by connecting them with trusted professionals and offering support throughout each phase. Empower buyers to make informed choices by presenting them with relevant market data, comparative property analyses, and objective recommendations.

    Ultimately, guiding buyers through the buying process is about instilling confidence, trust, and assurance. Be their sounding board, their advocate, and their partner in this journey. By doing so, you'll foster meaningful relationships that transcend the transaction, turning buyers into loyal clients and enthusiastic referrers.

    Navigating Obstacles and Challenges

    Dealing with Unresponsive Buyers

    Fighting gatekeeping with access is the key when handling unresponsive buyers. Don't let their silence discourage you. Remember that 80% of sales require five follow-ups on average, and decision-makers are often just busy. Stay persistent and try diverse communication channels, like phone, email, or social media, to grab their attention.

    Incorporate consistency in your follow-ups by spacing them out at reasonable intervals. Offering value in each interaction is essential. Address their pain points or share useful content related to the property or market insights to pique their interest. Most importantly, be patient and empathetic. Understand that each buyer has their unique pace and reasons for being unresponsive.

    Lastly, learn the art of identifying when it's time to let go. Attempt different methods, but if they continue to ignore you, respectfully send a final email explaining your intent to disengage. This communicates your sincerity while leaving the door open for future communication.

    Overcoming Objections

    Fighting misinformation with transparency and providing clear, concise information is the key to overcoming objections. Listen actively to the buyer's concerns and take time to understand the underlying reasons. Empathize with their situation and offer tailored solutions that cater to their specific needs.

    Utilize your knowledge of the property and the market to address any uncertainties. Back up your statements with facts, metrics and, if necessary, provide access to additional resources. Don't be afraid to think outside the box. Offer creative solutions, such as flexible financing options or showcasing comparative properties, to give the buyer a well-rounded perspective.

    Lastly, always be honest with your buyers. If you can't directly address their objections, acknowledge the limitations and focus on highlighting the benefits and positives of the property in question. Trust and honesty go a long way in nurturing relationships with buyers.

    Closing a Sale with Confidence

    Fighting complexity with simplicity is crucial when it comes to closing a sale. Be clear and straightforward when discussing the purchasing process. Guide the buyer step by step, ensuring they're well-informed and confident in their decision-making.

    Throughout the negotiation process, display confidence and reassure the buyer of your expertise. Collaborate with the buyer to arrive at a win-win, mutually beneficial agreement. Being flexible in your approach and accommodating their requests can help facilitate a smooth sale closure.

    After securing an agreement, follow up with a detailed summary of the next steps, and offer continued support as needed. Maintain an open line of communication and be readily available to address any queries or concerns. By mastering the art of closing sales with confidence, you'll be well-equipped to handle any challenges that come your way.


    In conclusion, building a shortlist of interested buyers is essential for any real estate professional seeking to maximize their success in the industry. By leveraging powerful tools such as, identifying key indicators of serious buyers, and maintaining a dynamic and effective shortlist, you can target your follow-up efforts with precision and achieve your desired results. Furthermore, master the art of personalized communication, guiding buyers through the buying process, and confidently closing sales to foster long-lasting relationships and drive your business growth. Embrace the strategies outlined in this post, and you'll be well on your way to a thriving real estate empire.

    Looking for a comp? Explore homes near you at

    Ready to sell? Start a listing for free today at

    We'd love to hear your thoughts about this article and our blog. Let us know how we did by completing the Unreal Estate Blog Feedback Survey.

    Unreal Estate stacked logo



    Updated January 2023: By using this website, you agree to our Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.

    ⁠Unreal Estate holds real estate brokerage licenses under the following names in multiple states and locations:
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a, LLP)
    Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a USRealty Brokerage Solutions, LLP)
    Unreal Estate Brokerage LLC
    Unreal Estate Inc. (f/k/a Abode Technologies, Inc. (dba
    Main Office Location: 991 Hwy 22, Ste. 200, Bridgewater, NJ 08807
    California DRE #01527504
    New York § 442-H Standard Operating Procedures
    TREC: Info About Brokerage ServicesConsumer Protection Notice


    If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Unreal Estate Customer Support for help at 1-866-534-3726 
    Open Monday – Friday 9:00 – 5:00 EST with the exception of holidays.

    *See Terms of Service for details.

    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon

    © 2023 Unreal Estate Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    Unreal Estate certified trust badge
    LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon